Best Served Cold, by Joe Abercrombie

I came across Joe Abercrombie when I had lunch with some people from Orbit, the science fiction publisher, a few weeks ago, and they mentioned him. They publish Abercrombie, so their objectivity is hopelessly compromised, but I put him on my list anyway. Then I was reminded of him when I was obsessively checking the Amazon UK page for my book and I saw that you could order his and my book together, and that his book was outselling mine by like a mazillion orders of magnitude. (He and I may be the only authors in or out of Christendom to be blurbed by both Junot Diaz and George R. R. Martin.)

Abercrombie writes dark, adult fantasy, by which I mean there's a lot of stabbing in it, and after people stab each other they sometimes have sex with each other. His tone is morbid and funny and hard-boiled, not wholly dissimilar to that of Iain Banks. Best Served Cold begins with the heroine, a mercenary named Monzcarro Murcatto -- thankfully it gets abbreviated to Monza -- getting thrown over the wall of a castle and down a mountain.

Amazingly Monza survives. Not so amazingly she swears revenge on the seven people who tried to kill her. The rest of the book is story of her attempts to kill them.

This premise allows Abercrombie to march Monza the length and breadth of his fictional kingdom of Styria, collecting a ragged band of mercenaries along the way. As she works her way through the list, and becomes increasingly embroiled in the fate of Styria as a nation, he puts her through a series of wildly inventive combat sequences. Like Fritz Leiber he has a gift for describing hand to hand combat -- you can see in your head where the blades are going, what is clanging off what, the sweat, the blood, the banter.

And like George R. R. Martin Abercrombie has the will and the cruelty to actually kill and maim his characters. Monza is a badass, but she's not so badass that you always know what's coming next. No one is ever safe. Volumetrically speaking, it's hard to think of another fantasy novel in which this much blood gets spilled.

Not that Best Served Cold is just fight after fight. The arc of the story is about revenge, and why people want it, and what you actually have once you get it. Abercrombie does a particularly good line in witty nihilists, men and women who've been killing so long that they're past the horror of it, but not past the humor of it. "You were a hero round these parts," someone tells Monza. And then by way of clarification: "That's what they call you when you kill so many people the word murder falls short."

Comments (15)

Post a Comment »

  1. I keep hearing that I should read this book, but it sounds like something I'd hate. Yet all the people recommending it have impeccable taste.

    Ever get that feeling?

    Church

    Jul. 30, 2009 11:16:am

    at 11:16:am

  2. @ Church - I just had similar thoughts. I was going to add this to my to-read list when I realized that while I've read (and usually liked) several books based on Lev's recommendations, that it feels like a one way street for some reason....

    Kemper

    Jul. 30, 2009 11:56:am

    at 11:56:am

  3. @ Kemper - you mean you're upset that Lev doesn't take your recommendation for books? Does an elephant take culinary advice from its tire swing? Does a god get hair advice from a dachshund? Does a Cylon take programming advice from Daggit?

    dennitzio

    Jul. 30, 2009 13:18:pm

    at 13:18:pm

  4. @ dennitzio - I'd never be so arrogant as to recommend a book to a book critic. However, if he was a blogger covering geek culture I might sublety suggest that he check out one of the most acclaimed science fiction television programs of the last decade if it was also endorsed by some professional critical organization such as .. Oh, I don't know... Maybe the Televsion Critic's Association? Or his own magazine's TV critic? Hypothetically speaking, of course....

    Kemper

    Jul. 30, 2009 13:56:pm

    at 13:56:pm

  5. @ Kemper, why would it be arrogant to recommend a book to a book critic?

    hannef123

    Jul. 30, 2009 14:03:pm

    at 14:03:pm

  6. @ hannef123 - Two personal reasons:

    1) I can't even help browbeat one into watching a TV show even with empirical evidence that he should try it so I have the feeling that trying to convince him about trying something in his professional field would be like getting Col. Tigh to stop drinking.

    2) I'm just an ignoramus who can barely read the local Penny Saver so I wouldn't have the guts to try and recommend a book to a professional critic for fear of the scorn and ridicule that would probably follow.

    Kemper

    Jul. 30, 2009 14:13:pm

    at 14:13:pm

  7. @Kemper

    Penny Saver? Are you a Baltimoron?

    Church

    Jul. 30, 2009 14:15:pm

    at 14:15:pm

  8. Kansas City. I think it's nationwide. Or maybe I just remember it from watching Juno and thought it was the same as the local ads. Things get jumbled in my head sometimes. I blame the media....

    Kemper

    Jul. 30, 2009 14:19:pm

    at 14:19:pm

  9. @ Kemper... there can be great literature in the Penny Saver. :O)

    hannef123

    Jul. 30, 2009 15:04:pm

    at 15:04:pm

  10. Never realized they had such a big website. Thanks, Kemper, for the recommendation! http://www.pennysaverusa.com/

    dennitzio

    Jul. 30, 2009 15:24:pm

    at 15:24:pm

  11. I can't get Lev to watch BSG, but I can completely derail his thread and hook dennitzio up with Penny Saver so I'm going call it a good day's work.....

    Kemper

    Jul. 30, 2009 15:40:pm

    at 15:40:pm

  12. Not that Best Served Cold wasn't great, but Abercrombie's "First Law" series (that this follows) is much better. I couldn't name a fantasy series with more highly developed characters. Abercrombie really draws you into their world.

    drad098

    Jul. 30, 2009 19:33:pm

    at 19:33:pm

  13. Speaking of great books with highly developed characters... Has anyone read the Third Chronicles of Thomas Covenant? The first two sets were some of my favorite books, and I like a lot of his other books. But I don't want to ruin my memories of the other books if these suck...

    dennitzio

    Jul. 30, 2009 22:35:pm

    at 22:35:pm

  14. @ drado98... I heard from some fellow book geeks that the First Law series ended in a very unsatisfying manner, so I have been hesitant to pick it up and begin it.

    hannef123

    Jul. 31, 2009 08:43:am

    at 08:43:am

  15. dennitzio - so far I've enjoyed the Third Chronicles. I wouldn't say they suck by any means.

    Cliff

    Jul. 31, 2009 19:52:pm

    at 19:52:pm