By now you've seen Verizon's iDon't/DROID Does campaign on TV or on the streets. The first commercial can be found here. It's a bit tongue-in-cheek and Verizon has admitted this, but it does highlight a handful of things that the iPhone clearly cannot do. It should also serve as a clear indication that any rumor of the iPhone moving to the network is now squashed. Or they're confident enough that Apple won't hold a grudge. The former scenario is more likely. (See the best travel gadgets of 2009.)
Motorola's DROID has a very industrial look and feel to it. Gone are the days of lightweight and dainty devices. You don't have to coddle the DROID or shell out an extra $30 for a case. Wrapped mostly in metal, the DROID is chock-full of features that have become standard on ‘smartphones' or whatever else you want to call these mini computers. Here's a quick rundown on features and specs:
Network: Verizon Wireless (CDMA 1X 800/1900, EVDO rev. A)
Operating System: Android v2.0
Processor: Arm Cortex A8 processor 550mHz
Memory: 256MB built-in, ships with 16GB microSD card (expandable to 32GB)
Display: 3.7-inch capacitive touchscreen (480x854)
Camera: 5-megapixel with dual-LED flash, auto-focus and image stabilization
Browser: Webkit HTML5, Flash Player 10.1 ready (coming soon)
GPS: aGPS/sGPS
Bluetooth: v2.1+EDR
Wi-Fi: 802.11b/g
Battery: 1400 mAh battery
Sensors: proximity, ambient light and eCompass
Size/Weight: 2.4 x 4.6 x 0.5 in., 6 oz.
DROID's 3.7-inch display is the best looking capacitive touchscreen we've ever seen on any device. It renders images and text beautifully. Colors appear to pop right off the screen. In other words, you can read e-mail, browse Web pages, read eBooks or comics for hours without suffering major eye fatigue. Touch response is good and most taps are registered with very little lag or issue. But the DROID is the only Android device running version 2.0, so it's difficult to say whether or not it's perfect. There's very little evidence to dispute this claim, though.
Just below the screen are four touch-sensitive buttons: back, menu, home and search. For some odd reason, Motorola has excluded buttons dedicated to initiate or end phone calls. You'll have to initiate the dialer from one of three home screens that you can use to populate various applications or widgets. The buttons are awkwardly placed and often times, we inadvertently tapped the search button when doing anything one-handed (right hand of course). A short tap of the search button will bring up Google Search and the virtual keyboard. A long press initiates Google's Voice Search, which works amazingly well. The rest of the buttons are pretty self-explanatory. Home takes you back to the home screen and so on. (See the top iPhone applications.)
Underneath the screen is an offset full QWERTY keyboard and directional pad. Anyone used to a BlackBerry or Sidekick will feel at home with the DROID's keyboard, but will quickly find that it doesn't offer the same experience. The keys are a tad cramped and there isn't enough tactile feedback making it difficult to know where your thumbs are without having to look down. It works and is by no means a deal breaker, but depending on how big or small your hands, you'll want to check one out in person. The directional pad is great for navigating through mobs of text but doesn't offer much else. (Watch TIME's video "iPhone vs. BlackBerry: Which Wins?")
On top of the DROID, you'll find the on/off switch and 3.5mm headset jack. Around the upper right corner on the right rail, the chintzy volume switch does it what it needs to do. The lower left corner is where the camera button has been placed in all its brown sugar colored glory.
Moving to the back of the device you'll find the 5-megapixel camera and brown sugar colored speaker. The camera is horrible. Probably the worst of any phone on the market and there are a lot of bad camera phones on the market. Start up takes a long time, focusing takes even longer if it can even manage to focus and then you may as well pull out the La-Z-Boy while it takes the image. However, we're confident that an over-the-air (OTA) update will remedy the situation as it doesn't appear to be a hardware issue and mainly a software one. The jury is out until Motorola tries to fix this flaw. (See pictures of the cell phone's history.)
First and foremost, the DROID is a phone, which is something people seem to forget when fawning over the latest devices. Does it make it phone calls? Yes. Will you experience dropped calls like your iPhone user friends? No. Verizon's 3G network is the nation's largest and it's close to perfect. The caller and receiver sound crisp and clear. The speakerphone is loud and clear.
Shoddy battery life from any 3G device with GPS, a Web browser, Wi-Fi are commonplace, but the DROID seems to be ahead of the pack. Mileage will vary here, but light Web browsing, sporadic app usage, background tasks, a phone call or two and Gmail will have you running anywhere from 10-14 hours. Certain measures can be taken to lengthen your battery life, like switching from 3G to EDGE (d'oh), lowering screen brightness and turning off GPS, but it's something we all have to deal with these days. (See the 50 best websites of 2009.)
From a hardware standpoint, the DROID flies but the software will either take advantage of the hardware in a manner that offers a flawless user experience or it'll crap its pants trying to take a picture.
Android became a viable contender with version 1.6. Check out the video below.
And here's what new with 2.0.
Google Maps Navigation (BETA) is a major coup for Verizon and Motorola. It offers free turn-by-turn voice commands as well as Street Views along your route so you can actually see what the upcoming turn will look like and it even says the full name of the street. A dedicated car mode allows you to use the device when driving hands free. It's driven purely by voice commands whether you're trying to call someone, find the closest gas station or plotting a new destination. But don't worry, it won't replace your Garmin or whichever PND you might currently own. It's a good start but it has a ways to go before it will actually replace your PND.
Android 2.0 also comes with Microsoft Exchange support (calendar too!), a better Web browser and more functional camera. But it doesn't support multitouch even though it's been proven to work relatively well in previous builds of the operating system. For whatever reason- legal or not- Google won't allow us to pinch to zoom on Web pages or when we're viewing images. Speaking of browsing the Web, 2.0 offers a more polished experience, but it still plays second fiddle to the iPhone's Safari browser and that's because there's official support for multitouch. (See the 25 best blogs of 2009.)
We're pretty sure the camera stinks because of the software. You can now fiddle with settings, but that becomes a moot point because of its lackluster performance. Multimedia playback continues to be a disappointment as well. There's no way to natively sync your music library so you're relegated to dragging and dropping files. There are, however, third party applications that will allow you to do so. With only 256MB of on-board storage, the DROID is limited to the amount of applications you can store and maybe even the possibility of not being able to run future updates of the OS. It was rumored that 2.0 would allow you to store apps to the external memory card, but that's obviously not true.
At $200, the DROID is without a doubt the best Android device currently available; it's also the best phone Verizon has to offer and it doesn't hurt that Verizon is the best network. Android, as a platform, has a come a long way and 2.0 adds more polish and sheen to the OS. It might not be as friendly as we'd like it to be, but it comes in right behind the iPhone in terms of a seamless user experience.













Thanks for this review. I've been holding out hope for Verizon to get the iPhone, but watching Android with interest as well. It's nice to see my carrier of choice finally getting some better phones. Perhaps by the time I'm ready for a new phone, all this will be perfected and I won't have to suffer so much iPhone envy.
meredith81
Nov. 5, 2009 18:17:pm
at 18:17:pm
I have a mytouch 3g on t-mobile, currently running android 1.6. yes, the camera's a little disappointingly slow, but i didn't buy it to be a camera.
overall, i'm in love with phone and looking forward to the 2.0 upgrade when tmobile (or google) rolls it out to the phones later this month (at least those are the rumors i'm hearing).
friends of mine who have an iPhone and have played with my phone prefer my phone overall, mainly because of the ease-of-use with all of the google-optimization which doesn't require any synching to use most of the features across a variety of devices.
Stephen Fofanoff
Nov. 5, 2009 18:46:pm
at 18:46:pm
How could you not mention the unbelievably ridiculous storage limitation? Apps can't run from the microSD card, so you are limited to the 256 MB to store apps (You can swap out apps from the storage to the MicroSD card, but that is incredibly inconvenient once you have a lot of apps on the phone)
0megapart1cle
Nov. 5, 2009 18:49:pm
at 18:49:pm
In my haste I did forget to mention that.
Peter Ha
Nov. 5, 2009 18:58:pm
at 18:58:pm
The TechCrunch review claims Droid is as good if not better than the iPhone. I guess it is all relative.
paramendra
Nov. 5, 2009 19:24:pm
at 19:24:pm
this article is flawed
Verizon does not have the best network
what they call 3g is actually 2.5g with ATT and Tmobile
they will not have anything close to IPhone's level until they upgrade to 4g
even then the digital network will be limited as with SPrint
Sprint and Verizon never bothered to build completely new networks
they just patched up old ones
also, this author tends to make a lot of excuses for the crappy performance of the droid
it's heavy and digusting
i dare any seasoned cell phone user to try and end a conversation on this phone without using profanity
cb3620
Nov. 5, 2009 19:53:pm
at 19:53:pm
I have been waiting for all these new Android phones before I made my final decision with my wife. We are both avid PC users and not Mac users. We had to go with the iPhone. We tried the Sprint Moment, the T-Mobile Cliq, etc. and the iPhone is still the WAY smoother experience!!! I do like the slide out keyboards, but the iPhone 3GS is still a much better user experience by leaps and bounds. Not to mention the 3D performance on the Android phones is terrible compared to the iPhone from what we tried. We like Android's potential, but what the Android OS needs is better hardware to back it up. When we scrolled down through web pages on any of the Android phones it was choppy and laggy compared to the iPhone. They, the Android phones, seem underpowered and maybe newer revision OS updates will resolve this. Also Adobe Flash support is sorely needed on all these phones.
liqmat
Nov. 5, 2009 21:39:pm
at 21:39:pm
"Certain measures can be taken to lengthen your battery life, like switching from 3G to EDGE"
Um, EDGE = GSM. Verizon doesn't do GSM. That will make it hard to do that switch.
bleepssc
Nov. 5, 2009 21:42:pm
at 21:42:pm
[...] Motorola DROID review (Verizon Wireless) - Nerd World - TIME.com [...]
WOW the Droid is phugly - Page 3 - PreCentral Forums
Nov. 5, 2009 21:42:pm
at 21:42:pm
**WARNING** Please note that the Droid will NOT sync natively with standalone Outlook (IOW you MUST have exchange!).
Currently the only way around this is to share your Contacts & Calendar with the "cloud" via Google(Gmail, google calendar, etc) which will then sync with the Droid.
This defeats the idea of PRIVATE data remaining private.
Why should Google be any more trustworthy or better at security than Microsoft, Verizon or Comcast? They aren't and this is a deal breaker for me.
I am starting to look at the BlackBerry Storm 2 again as at least it does a direct USB sync with standalone Outlook out of the box.
moshek
Nov. 5, 2009 21:50:pm
at 21:50:pm
We are a long way from perfection when it comes to any technology. Having stated the obvious, it sounds like this Droid device has a lot to offer.
Can you tell me what is available or is scheduled to be available with regards to compatible software?
ewillig
Nov. 5, 2009 21:57:pm
at 21:57:pm
Wow, you really have no idea what you are talking about.
Verizon most definitely has a true 3G network (actually the largest 3G footprint of all carriers). The new Iphone (3Gs) is the only Iphone that is even capable of utilizing a 3G network, so I don't see how a device would have to be 4G (either LTE or WiMAX) to compare. Verizon's data network is EV-DO and ATT's is HSPA, both 3G technologies. T-Mobile just launched their 3G network earlier this year in limited markets.
engrf
Nov. 5, 2009 22:07:pm
at 22:07:pm
Can I make a phone call and surf the web at the same time with it?
juancarlosdeburbon
Nov. 5, 2009 23:19:pm
at 23:19:pm
Exactly the reason I'm sticking with my Blackberry. The direct sync with Outlook is indispensable for me.
depleteduraniumshells
Nov. 5, 2009 23:20:pm
at 23:20:pm
Any idea how it functions with Google Voice?
gaodaning
Nov. 5, 2009 23:40:pm
at 23:40:pm
There ARE ways to sync music. Ever heard of doubletwist, songbird, winamp, media player?? You can sync music with any of these apps. NO, itunes isn't the be all and end all. I know Apple likes to hold everyone's hand, but some people do have at least half a brain and can figure these things out by themselves.
C'mon man, at least do a little research before bashing.
darreno1
Nov. 5, 2009 23:43:pm
at 23:43:pm
I'm probably too enamored with my iPhone to switch, but I'm happy that there is finally serious competition.
Church
Nov. 5, 2009 23:44:pm
at 23:44:pm
I know about doubletwist and songbird. Not everyone is as savvy about these things and the assumption is that most folks use iTunes. You can't natively sync out of the box. Android isn't a mass market OS and that's the main point.
Peter Ha
Nov. 6, 2009 00:04:am
at 00:04:am
I've clearly been using GSM devices far too long. T-Mobile and AT&T are my primary carriers. It hasn't been until the Palm Pre, Sprint Hero (even though I've been using the European version) and now the Droid that I've really used CDMA carriers.
Peter Ha
Nov. 6, 2009 00:08:am
at 00:08:am
good to see some competition for iPhone. Eventually consumers would win the war. Let the war begin.
abhishekrawat
Nov. 6, 2009 00:09:am
at 00:09:am
[...] Read this article: Motorola DROID review (Verizon Wireless) – Nerd World – TIME.com [...]
Motorola DROID review (Verizon Wireless) – Nerd World – TIME.com » Mobile & Cell Phone Reviews, Videos, & News
Nov. 6, 2009 00:10:am
at 00:10:am
Google Voice works perfectly on the Droid. It works with every Android-based device.
Peter Ha
Nov. 6, 2009 00:19:am
at 00:19:am
Thanks for the article Peter. I find it nice to see someone that actually cares enough about their work to actually look at the comments posted & take the time to respond to the comments that are worthy of a response. That shows you really care about what you do, and the information you provide to Joe Q. Public.
Kudos to you sir.
blowjarn
Nov. 6, 2009 00:53:am
at 00:53:am
I agree these programs are not included in the box, but to imply there isn't a way to sync is misleading. Even the assumption that most folks use itunes is off the mark. RIM has their own media sync software and the majority of Blackberry users (bigger market than Apple) use that for syncing.
It's the one-track thinking and assumptions like these that help to influence what the average joe believes. If people only knew there were free, more functional programs on par with (and superior to) to itunes, maybe they would not build their world around it.
Now I do also place some blame for this ignorance on the makers of Android and other open source phones like the Pre. If they took the effort to include this info in their manuals, it would make life so much easier for the less informed.
darreno1
Nov. 6, 2009 01:26:am
at 01:26:am
iPhone fans should not underestimate the Droid. It has Google's support, killer free apps like Google Voice and Navigation. It is also rumored the NeuroMobile will be available on the Droid soon. I'm not ready to switch but it will get a decent market share.
johnter617
Nov. 6, 2009 02:56:am
at 02:56:am