There are great sci-fi films like Avatar and District 9, which go on to earn the accolades of Oscar voters and audiences around the globe. And then there are brilliant movies like Primer or Dark City, which are all but forgotten in the multiplex, reduced to cult hit status on video and DVD, leaving fans wondering where things went wrong.
We've surveyed a great many of these underrated sci-fi movie masterpieces. And now we're talking to some of the filmmakers behind these unsung gems. A couple weeks ago we interviewed Alex Proyas, the mastermind behind Dark City (and the director of the forthcoming Dracula: Year Zero). Joining Dark City on our list was 1997's Gattaca, the sci-fi thriller about a world of genetic purity, and the struggles of one naturally-born human (Ethan Hawke) in pursuing his dreams amid a repressive, stratified society. See our full review here.
We spoke to Ethan Hawke about what it was like to star in an underrated masterpiece:
What is it about Gattaca that has allowed the film to endure?
Gattaca is among the best first films in the history of cinema. I firmly believe this. Andrew Niccol is so smart; this movie announced the arrival of a really, really original mind.
Why do you think it passed through theaters without greater fanfare?
I know for a fact that the head of studio releasing at the time just didn't think it was that good. He didn't want to invest a lot money in it, and so it was kind of dumped into theaters without much promotion.
I know that Andrew worked really hard with whatever little campaign he had. But at the end of the day, you need exposure to educate viewers as to what the movie's about.
What was it about the project that jumped out at you, that made you want to get involved?
All you had to do was read the script. It was one of the best screenplays of that year, or any year. You sat down to read it, and it was all there – the smart ideas, the smart way of telling the story. Even the musical score to that movie, I think it's one of the most beautiful I've ever heard.
You mention the screenplay – is there any scene that jumps out at you, that's stayed with you through the years?
Oh yeah, I think it's one of my all-time favorite lines, when I say ‘I never saved anything for the swim back.' I love that. And when I was doing the film, I really felt very strongly that this is a film that will last. Ultimately, I think it was a really high-budget art film. More and more, there's no place for that, and it's a travesty. I feel like we've lost room in the movie theater for a whole genre of pictures. They can't make it anymore.
You just starred in the vampire thriller Daybreakers (Read the full Daybreakers interview). Would you do another film like that – step into another genre perhaps?
I would love to do another. I'm as big a fan of Lord of the Rings as anybody – I like good writing and when you read something like Andrew Niccol's script for Gattaca, it felt like reading a Beckett play for the first time. It felt awesome – like this is what they mean when they talk about art. When you find that kind of writing, that's where actors are supposed to go, and if you have to go do Planet of the Apes to find that sort of story, then you do it.
So maybe some Lord of the Rings swinging of the swords in your future?
Hell yeah.
Would you work with the Spierig brothers again? They're doing Captain Blood next, I believe..
Regardless of how well Daybreakers does, these guys made this movie that proves to the world they can make one hell of an entertaining movie. And I think they're setting Captain Blood in outer space, right? I think that's what I heard. I hope they say, 'Let's cast Ethan,' I would love to work with those guys again.







Hmm, I thought Truman Show came before Gattaca. (Yes, I know Andrew Niccol just wrote the Truman Show screenplay.) But maybe I'm wrong.
In any case, totally agree that the one-two punch of Gattaca and Truman Show announced the arrival of an amazingly talented storyteller.
So what the heck happened?
crispy
Feb. 3, 2010 13:17:pm
at 13:17:pm
S1m0ne happened
Lev Grossman
Feb. 3, 2010 13:33:pm
at 13:33:pm
Truman show actually came out the year after....that said, I think Ethan was referring to a first outing as director.
As for what happened, yes, S1m0ne didn't help at all. But I see he's already in production on another title (or at least I think he is): The Cross, which IMDB says is about "A man looks to cross a mysterious border that has never been crossed before."
I love how ambiguous that is. Suggests a movie that's thinking big, and definitely beyond your cookie-cutter plot. So maybe Niccol is on his way back??
Steven James Snyder
Feb. 3, 2010 14:55:pm
at 14:55:pm
I bought it on VHS ages ago after watching it by accident on a long flight. I'd never heard of the movie or Mr. Niccol at the time and only chose it because the alternatives were so abysmal and I like Uma Thurman.
All these many years later, fellow admirers of Mr. Niccol might be pleased to know that they recently showed a segment of Gattaca in my kids' school here in Spain. Apparently they only showed enough to establish the premise of the story for discussion in their ethics classes, so I encouraged them to watch the whole thing. My 16 yo's review, and I quote: "That's one hell of a story." That there is a rave.
I think Andrew Niccol is a force to be reckoned with, even S1m0ne was fun, Lord of War is brilliant.
benyoung2
Feb. 3, 2010 19:10:pm
at 19:10:pm