Hey Google Maps, Why Is Randolph, VT In A Lake?

Two months ago, Jessamyn West noticed something about the Google Maps location of her small town, Randolph, VT. Instead of being tucked somewhere in central Vermont, Google had moved the official location of Randolph into the middle of a lake.

(More on Techland: Little Old Lady Calls To Have Google Pac-Man Disabled)

"I was having some friends visit a couple months ago in April, and I was trying to explain to them how to get here and they asked, “Which Randolph do you live in?” But there's only one Randolph in Vermont. But they said, “No, no. There's one up by Randolph Center and one in the lake.” And they showed me if you type for just the name of the town, Randolph VT, it shows you a little dot in the middle of Lake Champlain, nowhere near here," she says. "It's 100 miles from here."

Left: Randolph, Vt. in its proper location (MapQuest) Right: Randolph as seen on Google Maps

The correct location for Randolph could be found by searching the town's zip code, 05060, or by using a full street address, but if you're searching Randolph the town, you might need a boat. Google's driving directions, comically, direct users to the edge of Lake Champlain. (Note: Other online maps, like MapQuest have Randolph in its correct spot.)

Mostly amused, West says she reported the problem to Google in hopes of seeing the snafu fixed. She said Google did reply to say that the problem would be corrected in the next 30 days, but nothing happened. She filed another report and waited. Still nothing.

"I tell other people in the town, most of them think it's funny," she says. "This is rural Vermont, most of (the people) don't even know what Google Maps is, much less what it means, so it's hard to even explain it. But still, nothing's really happening. And whatever, I like Google. I have no issue with Google, but this is really vexing. There appears to be no way to solve the problem."

(More on Techland: Was The Google Background Image Really That Bad?)

Then West says she remembered David Carroll, the musician who, while watching the cargo loaded onto his United Airlines flight, saw the rough handling that led to the damage of his guitar. Carroll and his band, Sons of Maxwell, took to YouTube, writing a series of United Breaks Guitars diddies, that went viral within weeks. With her friends, West joked that they should write a song of their own, alerting the world that Google had declared Randolph unofficially underwater.

She, along with her mother, boyfriend and a few friends wrote Hey Google, My Town's In The Lake, a funny ode to West's personal frustration with the search engine's mapping blip.

Still, West says, it's all in good fun for now ... just so long as the problem's fixed eventually. "It's not even that it's in the wrong location. It's in a place that physically, we cannot be."

Comments (4)

Post a Comment »

  1. In one month last fall, I clocked five errors serious enough to make me uncomfortable relying on Google Maps. One was egregious but understandable (my mother's house/fishing resort in the far rural areas was said to be about twenty five miles away; heaven help the customer that relies on Google). The others were occasions where I ended up driving around for twenty minutes before I finally called the destination for help, only to find that they were a couple of miles away and Google just got it wrong.

    In a couple of those cases, I went back to the web to try to debug the problem and figured it out: Google Maps gave me bad directions. No mistyping, mispelling or confusing address. Google Maps is simply unreliable. Weird and painful, if you ask me.

    tqwhite

    Jun. 12, 2010 08:59am

  2. Google is convinced that there is a Dunkin' Donuts in a little residential community near my brother's place in West Chester, PA. I went out one morning to bring back doughnuts for everybody, assuring them that my Droid could direct me. (Incidentally, Chrome's spellcheck just highlighted "Droid.")

    And instead, I was gone for an hour, after being misdirected to some dude's house in a cul-de-sac - right address and everything - but I didn't go up to his front door and demand doughnuts. Tacky.

    I then got pretty determined - "Doughnuts or death" sorta thing - and it took me an hour to drive to the nearest Dunkin' and back. (Well, okay, it shouldn't have taken that long, but then I turned off the GPS thing and figured I could make it on my own. Instead, I got hopelessly lost and then gave in half an hour later. So it should have taken only like 20 minutes.)

    dreinn

    Jun. 13, 2010 09:33am

  3. Google maps tried to send me the wrong way down a narrow one-way street. They fixed it promptly when I reported it to them.

    carold45

    Jun. 14, 2010 08:42am

  4. Seems to show the right location now. Funny how fast a problem can be fixed when it suddenly becomes publicly embarrasing

    cydonos

    Jun. 14, 2010 09:56am